I'm a fan of eBooks and eBook readers in general. And I dislike the fetishization of books as objects. This particular critique of eBooks isn't going to wallow in the supposed luxury of walls of books, or the smell of the paper, or the ability to jot notes on the flyleaf. As far as I'm concerned, the most important part of a book is the words. The physical book is just the box the present comes in. And also, I would like to point out that eBooks can't get mildewed or basement-y.
However, in thinking about eBooks lately, I have come across two potential problems. I find these troubling indeed. We may not be able to stop the wholesale rush to eBook gold, but we should start discussing these problems now before it's too late.
Problem #1: EBook Readers Aren't Free
Currently an eBook reader costs several hundred dollars. And the trend is toward heavily DRMed books, which means that if you want to read the Kindle edition you have to do it on a Kindle, and if you have a Kindle you can only read the Kindle version.
If we allow this draconian DRM to continue, it will stifle the ability of the market to put out a cheap $10 knock-off eBook reader. (Which is precisely what eBook production companies are fighting against.)
So what happens to the poor, the working poor, and the lower middle-class? In a world where most books are published on a proprietary eBook format, reading suddenly becomes a hobby of the well-to-do. It's hard enough to convince people to read; dropping a barrier to entry of several hundred dollars for an eBook reader is going to stop most people cold.
Will elementary schools issue eBook readers to their students? Will libraries let you check out an eBook reader? Will charities spring up to distribute free eBook readers to the community? How will libraries work, if everything's gone to eBooks? What will happen to second-hand bookstores? I don't know about you, but I rarely pay full cover price for a book. I either check it out from the library or buy it from a used bookstore. This won't be possible with eBooks, as the technology and DRM currently stands.
Problem #2: Serendipity
If you listen to people's stories about their early reading experiences, they all follow the same pattern. A child stumbles upon a book (usually one which is far too advanced for their tender young age) which sparks their life-long love of reading.
"I bought it for a nickel at a yard sale."
"I bought it for a dollar at a truck stop."
"I found it in my grandmother's attic."
"My parents put it on the highest bookshelf, but I dragged over a chair."
"Our neighbor gave me a huge box of books when they moved away."
These are all real-world examples. I'm sure you have your own! These chance encounters with free or very cheap books will not be possible with eBooks.

