For some reason, the theatrical release of "Golden Compass" created a strained argument over whether Philip Pullman argues against C.S. Lewis' God.
The argument was monumentally silly; of course Pullman is an atheist, and of course he "hates" Chronicles of Narnia "with a deep and bitter passion," as he put it. Of course "His Dark Materials" shadow-steps Narnia in plot mechanics and in photo-negative thematics. When children are in over their heads, they need (or need not) turn to Help.
What I don't understand, is why the argument wasn't simply about whether Dark Materials, or Narnia, present the more helpful worldview.
In any case, this mini-overview isn't intended to rebut Pullman, nor to demonstrate the vapidity of his worldview. It's offered more as a quick-scan of a few plot elements for those who perhaps have not read the books, so that such readers might decide whether Dark Materials is likely to be worth their time.
...............
Read more